Patient Details: 17510000344828
Mrs. Patralekha Chakraborty / Female / 53 Years 5 days of 277 B.B. Chatterjee Road, Kolkata – 700042
Under Treatment of Doctor: Dr. Binayak Deb
Angiogram and Angioplasty on 30/09/2013 (CAG + PTCA)
Discharge Date: 02/10/2013
Date of Death: 11/11/2013
My wife Patralekha Chakraborty was admitted to Rabindranath Tagore International Institute of Cardiac Sciences on 27/09/2013 with minor chest pain. She was admitted to the emergency ward and later transferred to ICU. After undergoing all the related tests, Dr. Binayak Deb was of the opinion that Angiogram and Angioplasty was the only solution available. She underwent angiogram and angioplasty on 30/09/2013 and got discharged on 02/10/2013. The doctor categorically explained and convinced us for undergoing angioplasty for above mentioned patient and assured us that this will deter any heart problems for the next 10 to 15 years. After the discharge we tried getting in touch with the doctor several number of times complaining about certain issues patient was facing however the doctor denied giving us any appointment. We were scheduled to take the patient after 1month to the hospital for a complete checkup and overview under the guidance of Dr. Deb. The doctor even denied us this opportunity and in the meantime we were forced to consult other doctor due to his utter disrespect for his professional commitments. On 11/11/2013 suddenly my wife started suffering a major breathing problem at around 3:30pm and we immediately planned to take her to RN Tagore Hospital. Since her health was deteriorating fast we were forced to take her to Ruby General Hospital which was closer to our house. However unfortunately she expired at around 4:15pm at Ruby General Hospital. The doctors at the hospital we took to (Ruby General Hospital) and our family doctor confirmed that it was a case of a Massive Heart Attack.
Now my question is if the patient dies just after 40 days of angioplasty then what is the benefit of doing Angioplasty? If the doctor was not sure of the result of Angioplasty then why not this doctor advice us for Bypass Surgery? After thinking about various angles we felt that either doctor would have used the inferior quality stent or it would be sheer carelessness of doctor for implantation of stent. We felt the chances of using inferior quality stent is more because doctors can earn more money in less time otherwise he could have suggested Bypass surgery which is more of time consuming work.
Though the above mentioned allegations by us cannot be conclusively proved since the patient is no more however the carelessness and arrogance of the doctor towards the patient and after she was discharged from the hospital can be proved without a doubt.
We understand that life and death is natural process but we want take action against the doctor’s arrogance and carelessness attitude in treating his patient. We hereby request you to take action against Dr. Binayak Deb so that in near future atleast he should realize our pain and refrain himself from treating patients with such arrogance and carelessness and your action can safeguard ones life.
Complaint against Dr. Binayak Deb of RN Tagore Hospital, Kolkata
Comments
5 responses to “Complaint against Dr. Binayak Deb of RN Tagore Hospital, Kolkata”
-
Very sorry to hear about your wife’s demise. What you have explained can be categorized as a criminal offence. A doctor is bound to attend to his/ her patients in times of need or arrange for a suitable alternative in case he isn’t available.
You should take this up with the court and sue both the doctor and the hospital. I am shocked that a doctor practicing in a hospital that carries Dr Devi Shetty’s name could be so arrogant and callous. He deserves strict legal action
Once again, very sorry for your less. Kindly accept my deepest condolences
-
Complaint Against Dr. Binayak Deb – RN Tagore Hospital, Kolkata ,India
We visited RTIICS for my husband’s a checkup In cardiology. We saw lot hospitality and professionalism in the hospital staff. Head doctor, Dr. Binayak Deb, was very helpeful than we expected and at all times, he made sure that he or his team was there for all the tests. Thanks to them
-
Verry Sorry for ur wife, My Father also suffring this problem. Ater reed ur all atatement i got lots of Ideas. Like How the Doctors change the STENT. I think like that type of THEFF DOCTORA SHOLUD ALSO DIA By the GOVT.
-
i have had previous experience in this hospital during its initial years. it was managed mostly by women back then and it was pleasure ride all along. meanwhile this time around it has been a hell and nightmare. the epitome of west bengal medical (Business) mismanagement is RN tagore. even the simplest of process is followed by red tapism, harassment and inflicting trouble to already ill patient and their families is something that has engulfed most of such hospitals which are nothing but petty businesses which take advantage of the vulnerability of people. i hope this reaches out to some govt officials and some governing bodies are put forward to streamline the disgraceful condition of such under managed institutions. and yes i have witnessed this with more than one hospital, but RN tagore tops the list and i have sufficient proof to validate my issues. especially ones who have medical insurance stay away from these Hospitals which are nothing but HOTELS with an added sophisticated care (perhaps a Better spa facility) sans the Hospitable hotel staff who understand management 100 times better than them. and the biggest gamble is after all the money spent and time lost for their below average service you are always in a dilemma whether everything was sufficient enough to get your patient out without passive aggression or in health. we who have dealt in management in our respective professions can understand the basic folly and yet i admit the hospitals take credit in mutilating the morals of the patient’s family. good job
-
i also think that doctor would be punshied by court for his money earning and not treating the patient how short of person he not trying his best to keep a patient well i think that court give to Dr.Binayak Deb life time jail and think the doctor what mistake i have done with my patient.very sad i am listening your some views by reading of your wife death.
Leave a Reply